Best 215/55R17 All-Season Tires: 6 Picks and Fit Guide

This guide compares six 215/55R17 all-season tires sold on Amazon, from the performance-oriented Pirelli P Zero All Season to budget XL-rated options such as the Fullway HP108 and Landspider Citytraxx H/P. We have not road-tested them: the details below come from the listings and from manufacturer and retailer spec pages.

Disclosure: some links are Amazon affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Pick by load index first (94 or 98 on these tires), then by how you drive. Always confirm the size, load index and speed rating against your door-jamb placard or owner’s manual before ordering.

Quick picks: 215/55R17 all-season tires compared

Check fit before you buy

• Decode the size: 215 is the section width in millimeters, 55 is the sidewall height as a percentage of width, and 17 is the rim diameter in inches.
• Match the placard: use the tire size, load index and speed rating on your door-jamb sticker or in the owner’s manual as the minimum. See our guide to reading the door-jamb tire sticker.
• Load index: 94 means up to 1,477 lb per tire and 98 means up to 1,653 lb per tire. XL (extra load) tires reach their rating at the higher inflation pressure shown on your placard, so do not use the number on the sidewall as your daily pressure.
• Replace in sets: fit four matching tires when you can. If you replace only two, put them on the rear axle and follow your vehicle manual, especially on all-wheel drive.
• Check the DOT date: the four-digit code on the sidewall gives the week and year of manufacture. Avoid tires that have sat for years.

The 215/55R17 tires in detail

The listing describes a 215/55ZR17 radial with a 98 load index, W speed rating, XL load range and asymmetrical tread. A 98 index is rated for about 1,653 lb per tire, which is more margin than the 94-index tires in this list. It is sold as a set of 2, so order two sets if you want all four corners.

Retailer spec pages list the P Zero All Season in 215/55R17 94V. It is positioned as a sporty all-season for drivers who want sharper steering response than a touring tire gives. Tires in this class usually trade some tread life and snow traction for handling, so check the treadwear rating on the sidewall or spec page before buying.

Retailer spec pages list the Atrezzo SH408 in 215/55R17 94V. The listing highlights four circumferential grooves for water evacuation and a staggered lug pattern aimed at keeping noise down, plus a 55,000-mile limited warranty. Read the warranty terms on the listing, since limited warranties usually have conditions.

The Amazon link and the comparison table identify this tire as the Barkley Trackstar UHP, not the “Aphelios” name used in the earlier version of this article. Retailer pages list it in 215/55R17 94V. It targets sport sedans and performance-minded crossovers and is listed with a 50,000-mile limited warranty.

Retailer pages list the Citytraxx H/P in 215/55R17 98W XL, and the Amazon listing is a set of 4. The 420AA UTQG figure comes from the listing: 420 is the treadwear grade, and the two A grades are for wet traction and temperature resistance. It is a budget way to replace all four tires with a 98 load index.

Retailer spec pages list the Assurance MaxGuard in 215/55R17 94V. It is a mainstream all-season for commuting and highway driving from a well-known brand. Check the current treadwear warranty on the Goodyear or retailer page, because it is not stated in our listing data.

Looking at other sizes or wheel diameters? See 215/45R17 high-performance all-season tires, 17-inch all-season passenger tires and 17-inch touring all-season tires.

FAQ

What does 215/55R17 mean on a tire?

It means a 215 mm section width, a sidewall height of 55 percent of that width, a radial construction (R) and a 17-inch rim diameter. A tire must match the rim size, and your vehicle placard tells you which load index and speed rating to meet or exceed.

Should I buy a 94 or 98 load index tire?

Use the load index on your door-jamb placard or in the owner’s manual as the minimum. A 98 (XL) tire carries more than a 94, but it is not required unless your vehicle calls for it, and you should still inflate to the pressure on the placard.

Are 215/55R17 all-season tires good in snow?

All-season tires handle light snow and cold, wet roads, but they are not winter tires. For regular snow and ice, look for the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol on the sidewall or use dedicated winter tires.

When should I replace my tires?

Replace them when the tread reaches 2/32 inch, which is the legal minimum in most US states, and consider replacing earlier, around 4/32 inch, if you drive often in the rain. Also replace tires with cuts, bulges or age-related cracking, and check the DOT date on the sidewall.

What tire pressure should I use?

Use the cold-inflation pressure on your vehicle’s door-jamb placard, not the maximum pressure printed on the tire sidewall. Check it monthly with a gauge when the tires are cold.

Which one to choose

If handling is the priority, the Pirelli P Zero All Season and Barkley Trackstar UHP are the sporty picks. For quiet everyday driving at a lower price, look at the Sailun Atrezzo SH408 or the Goodyear Assurance MaxGuard. If you want a 98 load index, the Fullway HP108 and Landspider Citytraxx H/P are the XL options here. Confirm the size and load index on the listing before you order.

This Roundup is reader-supported. When you click through links we may earn a referral commission on qualifying purchases.