The best all-season tires for New England are the ones that match the size on your door placard and, ideally, carry the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) symbol. Below are 10 size-specific picks, from Michelin and Pirelli down to budget brands. If you see regular snow and ice, a dedicated winter tire is still safer than any all-season.
Disclosure: some links on this page are Amazon affiliate links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Specs here come from the Amazon listings, retailer pages and standard tire-code tables, not from road testing. Each tire fits only vehicles that use its size, so start with your placard.
| Lexani Quattro Tempo AW All Season P205/65R15 94H Passenger Tire |  | Best budget all-weather (15-inch) | Tire size: P205/65R15 | Type: All-weather | Load/speed: 94H | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 Tire |  | Best premium name (18-inch SUV) | Tire size: 245/60R18 | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 105H | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Firestone All Season Touring Tire 235/60R17 102 T |  | Best everyday touring (17-inch) | Tire size: 235/60R17 | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 102T | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Goodyear Eagle Touring All Season 245/45R20 99 V Tire |  | Best low-profile touring (20-inch) | Tire size: 245/45R20 | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 99V | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Forceum Penta All-Season Truck/SUV Performance Tires 225/65R17 (4-Pack) |  | Budget SUV four-pack (17-inch) | Tire size: 225/65R17 | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 106H | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire 235/50R18/XL 101V |  | Best long-life all-season (18-inch) | Tire size: 235/50R18 XL | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 101V | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Forceum Octa All-Season Performance Tires Set of 4 |  | Also consider: budget sporty compact (16-inch) | Tire size: 205/55R16 | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 94W | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Travelstar UN99 All Season 225/60R17 Tire Set of 4 |  | Budget four-pack (17-inch) | Tire size: 225/60R17 | Type: All-season (M+S) | Load/speed: see listing | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Fullway HP108 All-Season Passenger Car Tires (Set of 4) |  | Also consider: budget compact (16-inch) | Tire size: 205/55R16 | Type: All-season | Load/speed: 91V | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Lexani LXUHP-207 245/45ZR18 100W XL All Season Performance Tire |  | Also consider: performance (18-inch), not for snow | Tire size: 245/45ZR18 | Type: All-season performance | Load/speed: 100W | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Lexani Quattro Tempo AW All Season P205/65R15 94H Passenger Tire
Lexani sells the Quattro Tempo AW as an all-weather passenger tire. Retailer pages for the line show the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) symbol, an asymmetric ribbed tread and a 50,000-mile treadlife warranty. Confirm the snowflake marking and the warranty terms for this exact size before you order.
Fit check: Fits cars that use P205/65R15. Check the door placard first.
- Tire size:P205/65R15
- Load index / speed rating:94H (1,477 lb per tire, up to 130 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-weather
- Tread (retailer pages):Asymmetric, ribbed
- Treadlife warranty (retailer pages):50,000 miles, limited
Pros
- 3PMSF marking shown on retailer pages for the line
- Small 15-inch size for older compact cars
- Asymmetric ribbed tread
Cons
- Fits only vehicles that use 205/65R15
- Lesser-known brand; read the warranty terms
Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 Tire
The Scorpion All Season Plus 3 is Pirelli’s year-round tire for crossovers, SUVs and light trucks. This listing is for 245/60R18 with a 105H rating. Pirelli quotes a treadwear warranty on many sizes of this tire; confirm the figure for 245/60R18 on the listing or with Pirelli, and check the sidewall for the snowflake symbol if winter rating matters to you.
Fit check: Fits crossovers and SUVs that use 245/60R18. Confirm against your placard.
- Tire size:245/60R18
- Load index / speed rating:105H (2,039 lb per tire, up to 130 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Name-brand all-season for CUVs and SUVs
- 105 load index suits heavier crossovers
- H speed rating
Cons
- Higher price class than budget brands
- Only fits vehicles that use 245/60R18
Firestone All Season Touring Tire 235/60R17 102 T
Firestone’s All Season is a mainstream touring tire. This listing is 235/60R17 102T, a common crossover size, with a symmetrical tread. The listing cites a limited treadwear warranty; confirm the mileage and conditions for this size. It is an all-season tire, not a winter-rated one.
Fit check: Fits vehicles that use 235/60R17. Not winter-rated.
- Tire size:235/60R17
- Load index / speed rating:102T (1,874 lb per tire, up to 118 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Familiar brand and common 17-inch crossover size
- Symmetrical tread suits regular rotation
- 102 load index
Cons
- T speed rating is lower than H or V
- No snowflake marking listed
Goodyear Eagle Touring All Season 245/45R20 99 V Tire
Goodyear’s Eagle Touring is an all-season grand-touring tire. This listing is 245/45R20 with a 99V rating, a low-profile 20-inch size found on some larger sedans and crossovers. Low-profile tires give up some cushioning on rough, pothole-prone roads, so weigh that if your roads are rough.
Fit check: Fits vehicles that use 245/45R20. Thin sidewalls are tougher on frost-heaved roads.
- Tire size:245/45R20
- Load index / speed rating:99V (1,709 lb per tire, up to 149 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Name-brand touring tire
- V speed rating
- Low-profile 20-inch size
Cons
- Thin sidewall is less forgiving on potholes
- No snowflake marking listed
Forceum Penta All-Season Truck/SUV Performance Tires 225/65R17 (4-Pack)
Forceum Penta is a budget all-season line for SUVs and light trucks. This listing is a four-pack of 225/65R17 with a 106H XL rating according to the product page, an asymmetric tread and long circumferential grooves. Note that most 225/65R17 tires are rated 102H, so double-check the load index on the listing against your vehicle placard.
Fit check: Fits vehicles that use 225/65R17. The listed 106H rating is unusual for this size, so verify it.
- Tire size:225/65R17
- Load index / speed rating:106H (2,094 lb per tire, up to 130 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Four-pack in a common crossover size
- Higher load index than most 225/65R17 tires
- Water-channel grooves
Cons
- Little brand track record
- Not winter-rated
MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire 235/50R18/XL 101V
The Defender2 is Michelin’s long-life all-season touring tire. This listing is 235/50R18 XL with a 101V rating. Michelin publishes a treadwear warranty for Defender2, but the mileage differs by size and speed rating, so confirm it for 235/50R18 on Michelin’s site. It is an all-season tire without the snowflake symbol.
Fit check: Fits vehicles that use 235/50R18. Not winter-rated, so add winter tires if you see heavy snow.
- Tire size:235/50R18 XL
- Load index / speed rating:101V (1,819 lb per tire, up to 149 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Michelin tire built for long tread life
- V speed rating
- XL load rating
Cons
- Costs more than budget brands
- Not a snowflake-rated tire
Forceum Octa All-Season Performance Tires Set of 4
Forceum Octa is a budget all-season performance line. This listing is a four-pack of 205/55R16 with a 94W XL rating and a 400AA UTQG grade according to the product page, an asymmetric tread and circumferential grooves. It targets small cars on 16-inch wheels and is not meant for crossovers.
Fit check: Only for cars that use 205/55R16. Not a winter pick: it has no snowflake marking and a performance-style tread.
- Tire size:205/55R16
- Load index / speed rating:94W (1,477 lb per tire, up to 168 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Four-pack for 16-inch compact cars
- W speed rating
- Asymmetric tread with water grooves
Cons
- Little brand track record
- Not winter-rated
Travelstar UN99 All Season 225/60R17 Tire Set of 4
Travelstar UN99 is a budget all-season line. This listing is a four-pack of 225/60R17 tires only, so you need your own wheels. The product page cites M+S marking, wide drainage channels and a mileage warranty. M+S is not the same as the snowflake symbol, so treat it as light-snow capable at best.
Fit check: Fits vehicles that use 225/60R17. M+S only, so do not count on it in deep snow.
- Tire size:225/60R17
- Load index / speed rating:Not listed in the product title
- Type (per listing):All-season (M+S)
Pros
- Four-pack in a common crossover size
- M+S marking
- Water-drainage grooves
Cons
- Load index not given in the title
- No snowflake marking listed
Fullway HP108 All-Season Passenger Car Tires (Set of 4)
Fullway HP108 is a budget all-season passenger line. This listing is a four-pack of 205/55R16 with a 91V rating and an asymmetric tread according to the product page. It suits compact cars and hatchbacks that use this size.
Fit check: Only for cars that use 205/55R16. Not a winter pick for New England.
- Tire size:205/55R16
- Load index / speed rating:91V (1,356 lb per tire, up to 149 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season
Pros
- Four-pack for compact cars
- V speed rating
- Asymmetric tread
Cons
- Little brand track record
- Not winter-rated
Lexani LXUHP-207 245/45ZR18 100W XL All Season Performance Tire
Lexani LXUHP-207 is an ultra-high-performance all-season tire. This listing is 245/45ZR18 with a 100W XL rating and a V-shaped tread. Performance all-season tires usually trade some snow traction for dry handling, so this is not the first choice if you see regular snow.
Fit check: Only for vehicles that use 245/45ZR18. A performance tire is a weak choice for snowy New England roads.
- Tire size:245/45ZR18
- Load index / speed rating:100W (1,764 lb per tire, up to 168 mph)
- Type (per listing):All-season performance
Pros
- W speed rating for spirited driving
- V-shaped tread with wide grooves
- Sporty 18-inch size
Cons
- Performance compound is weaker in snow
- Fits few vehicles in this size
All-season tire sizes and ratings at a glance
Use this table to match a tire to your vehicle. Sizes come from the product titles; load and speed figures come from the standard tables for the index in the title.
| Tire | Size | Load index / speed rating | Type | Fit for this guide |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lexani Quattro Tempo AW | P205/65R15 | 94H (1,477 lb per tire, up to 130 mph) | All-weather | Cars on 205/65R15 |
| Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3 | 245/60R18 | 105H (2,039 lb per tire, up to 130 mph) | All-season | Crossovers on 245/60R18 |
| Firestone All Season Touring | 235/60R17 | 102T (1,874 lb per tire, up to 118 mph) | All-season | Vehicles on 235/60R17 |
| Goodyear Eagle Touring | 245/45R20 | 99V (1,709 lb per tire, up to 149 mph) | All-season | Vehicles on 245/45R20 |
| Forceum Penta | 225/65R17 | 106H (2,094 lb per tire, up to 130 mph) | All-season | Vehicles on 225/65R17 |
| Michelin Defender2 | 235/50R18 XL | 101V (1,819 lb per tire, up to 149 mph) | All-season | Vehicles on 235/50R18 |
| Forceum Octa | 205/55R16 | 94W (1,477 lb per tire, up to 168 mph) | All-season | Compact cars on 205/55R16 |
| Travelstar UN99 | 225/60R17 | Not listed in title | All-season (M+S) | Vehicles on 225/60R17 |
| Fullway HP108 | 205/55R16 | 91V (1,356 lb per tire, up to 149 mph) | All-season | Compact cars on 205/55R16 |
| Lexani LXUHP-207 | 245/45ZR18 | 100W (1,764 lb per tire, up to 168 mph) | All-season performance | Vehicles on 245/45ZR18 |
Load and speed figures are standard tire-code values for the index printed in each product title; the maker and the Amazon listing have the final word.
How to choose all-season tires for New England
New England winters mix cold rain, slush, road salt and the occasional storm, so look beyond the label.
- Snowflake symbol: the 3PMSF mark means the tire passed a standard snow-traction test. A plain M+S mark only describes tread design.
- Cold-weather rubber: ordinary all-season compounds stiffen as it gets colder. All-weather and winter tires use compounds designed to stay softer.
- Tread depth: the legal minimum in most states is 2/32 inch, but snow and slush grip fades as tread wears. Many tire shops suggest replacing all-season tires for winter use at around 5/32 inch.
- Wet grip and hydroplaning: look for wide grooves and plenty of sipes (small slits) to clear slush and water.
- Noise and comfort: asymmetric and symmetric designs differ by model, so check owner feedback for the exact tire.
- Warranty: treadwear warranties are pro-rated and need regular rotation records. Read the terms before you buy.
Check the fit before you order
- Find the tire size and the load and speed rating on the placard inside the driver door jamb or in the owner manual.
- Buy the same size. Mixing diameters can upset the speedometer, ABS and all-wheel-drive systems.
- Choose a load index and speed rating at or above the placard values.
- Replace all four tires on AWD and 4WD vehicles, or follow the maker guidance, so the circumference matches.
- Check the DOT date code on arrival, since tires age even when unused.
When all-season tires are not enough
If you live where roads stay snow-packed or icy, or you drive hills and back roads before the plows, dedicated winter tires are the safer option. See our guide to all-season tires for snow and ice for what works best, and our list of all-season tires for SUVs if you drive a crossover.
Frequently asked questions
Are all-season tires good enough for New England winters?
They handle cold rain, slush and light snow, but they stop and turn worse than winter tires on packed snow and ice. A tire with the 3PMSF symbol is a better compromise. If you drive on unplowed roads, choose dedicated winter tires.
What does the snowflake symbol on a tire mean?
The Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake symbol on the sidewall means the tire passed a standardized snow-traction test. A plain M+S mark only describes the tread design and does not promise the same result.
When should I switch to winter tires in New England?
A common rule is to switch when temperatures stay near or below about 45 degrees Fahrenheit, because winter compounds stay softer in the cold. The exact date depends on your local climate and how much snow you see.
How much tread do I need for winter driving?
The legal minimum in most states is 2/32 inch, but traction in snow drops as tread wears. Many tire shops suggest replacing all-season tires for winter use at about 5/32 inch.
Can I mix all-season and winter tires on one vehicle?
Avoid it. Mixing tire types can change how the vehicle handles, especially on AWD and 4WD models. Fit a matching set of four and check your owner manual.
How do I know which of these tires fits my vehicle?
Match the size on your door placard to the sizes in the table above. Only buy a tire with the same size and a load and speed rating at or above the placard values.
Related reading:
Conclusion
For New England, put fit first, then snow rating. Pick the size on your placard, favor a 3PMSF-marked tire if you want an all-season that copes better with winter, and plan on winter tires if snow and ice are a regular part of your commute. Treat the listings above as starting points and confirm the details on each Amazon page.
